Abandoned cart recovery is one of the highest-ROI things you can automate, but most merchants are either paying for the wrong app or running the same channel twice. Here's how to pick the right one.
Baymard Institute's running average puts online cart abandonment at roughly 70%. Winning back even a small slice of those carts can be a real revenue lift, which is why abandoned cart recovery is usually worth investing in.
The complication is that "abandoned cart recovery" spans three different channels (email, SMS, and push notifications) and the app landscape covers all of them differently. Many merchants end up paying for overlapping coverage without realizing it.
Upload this month's invoice and see every app charge. First analysis free.
Install on the Shopify App Store| Channel | Requires | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Email capture at checkout | Low, often bundled | |
| SMS | Phone number + SMS consent | Medium, pay-per-send |
| Push notifications | Browser push opt-in | Low, subscriber-based |
Channel: Email + SMS
Best for: Stores with a real email list and desire to own their data
Pros
Cons
Verdict: The default choice for stores that want a real retention platform. If you're already paying for Klaviyo, you don't need a separate cart recovery app: the flow is built in.
Channel: SMS + Email
Best for: SMS-first brands with high AOV
Pros
Cons
Verdict: Best for brands where SMS is the primary retention channel and $300/mo is justified by volume. Don't run this alongside Klaviyo SMS: you'll pay twice for the same channel.
Channel: Push notifications
Best for: Supplementing email recovery with push
Pros
Cons
Verdict: Worth adding as a supplementary recovery channel, especially on free plan. Don't pay $50+/mo on this before maxing out email.
Channel: Live chat + email + basic automation
Best for: Small stores wanting live chat + basic abandoned cart in one app
Pros
Cons
Verdict: Good for small stores that want live chat and basic abandoned cart without managing two separate tools. Not a replacement for Klaviyo at scale.
Channel: Email
Best for: New stores or those with a small list
Pros
Cons
Verdict: Start here if you're under 500 contacts. Switch to Klaviyo once you need segmentation or are hitting $10K+/mo revenue.
The overlap trap
The most common cart recovery mistake isn't picking the wrong app: it's running two apps that cover the same channel. The most expensive version:
| Store stage | Recommended stack |
|---|---|
| Early stage (under $10K/mo) | Shopify Email (free): that's it for now |
| Growing ($10K–$100K/mo) | Klaviyo email flow + PushOwl free tier |
| Scaling ($100K+/mo) | Klaviyo email + Klaviyo SMS, don't add Recart on top |
| SMS-first brand with high AOV | Recart for SMS + Klaviyo for email (no SMS in Klaviyo) |
Related Articles
No duplicate channels
AppTrim spots overlapping apps on your Shopify invoice (including marketing tools covering the same channel) so you only pay for what you actually need.
Audit your stack freeFirst invoice free. No credit card.